Navigation

AI Search

Back to the Future: Gravner’s Journey

By Anna Obukhovskaia IWA

In Marc Millon’s book Italy in a Wine Glass, Gravner’s Ribolla Gialla appears last, at the close of a chapter whose title reads almost like a manifesto: “Back to the Future.” It is hard to imagine a more fitting place for a wine that changed our idea of the future by returning to methods eight thousand years old. In Millon’s conversation with Mateja Gravner, Joško’s daughter, the story of that return emerges not as a romantic tale of amphorae, but as the result of a long and restless search. It is the story of a man who, in pursuit of a better wine, gradually gave up almost everything we have come to regard as progress.

…when it all began with disaster

In June 1996, hail struck Oslavia twice in the space of twenty-four hours. The first storm came on 19 June, the second the following day. By evening, the Gravner family had lost 95 per cent of its crop. The estate would normally produce between 35,000 and 40,000 bottles. That year, barely a thousand kilograms of grapes remained on the vines—perhaps enough for five or six hundred bottles, but no more. Joško Gravner did not buy grapes from his neighbours, nor did he try to make up the shortfall with finished wine. Instead, he wrote to every client: there would be virtually no 1996 vintage; all they could do was hope for the following year. For the winery, it was a catastrophe. For Joško, it was a rare opportunity to attempt an experiment that would have seemed reckless in a normal year.

He divided the small quantity of surviving Ribolla Gialla into separate lots. One fermented without the skins, another on them. In one, he used cultured yeasts; in another, he allowed indigenous yeasts to start the fermentation. He dispensed with temperature control and watched.

When he tasted the young wine fermented on its skins, without cultured yeast or artificial cooling, something happened towards which he had been moving for years: at last, he recognised the taste of Ribolla itself. The answer was at once obvious and radical. The finest grapes had failed to give him the finest wine because, in the cellar, he had been diligently removing the very thing that made them what they were.

The land with a border drawn through it

The Gravners’ home—Oslavia—lies in Friuli-Venezia Giulia, almost on the Slovenian border. But “almost” is not quite the right word here: some of the family’s vineyards lie on the Italian side, others on the Slovenian one. At home, the Gravners speak Slovenian and belong to Italy’s Slovenian minority. Their family has lived here since 1901, when Oslavia was part of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.

Over the course of a single century, local people changed passports several times without changing their homes. After the First World War, the land became part of the Kingdom of Italy. The border between Italy and Yugoslavia then lay some forty kilometres east of where it runs today; even Vipava, now unhesitatingly considered part of Slovenia, was within Italy. Later, the line shifted once again.

On these hills, the border has never looked particularly convincing. The same varieties grow on either side, the same rains fall and the same slopes roll on. Collio and Brda were once simply the Italian and Slovenian names for the same geographical area. Today, they are two wine regions divided by a national frontier. “Borders are almost never natural,” says Mateja Gravner, Joško’s daughter. “They are a human invention, and rarely a delicate or polite one.”

The word “borderland” captures the essence rather well, and perhaps this is precisely why Gravner’s wines fit so poorly into any category. White, yet built on tannic structure. Ancient in method, radically modern in intent. Italian by winery address, Slovenian by family language, Georgian by the origin of their vessels—and Oslavian through and through.

Gravner wine before the way we know it

In 1901, Gravner was not a wine brand. It was an ordinary mixed farm: grapes, cherries, apricots, vegetables, cows and pigs. Wine was made, but sold largely in bulk. It did not exist separately from food, farm or family; it was neither a collector’s object nor a means of declaring one’s taste. It was simply placed on the table. And the table was very large.

In old family photographs from the 1930s to the 1950s, six, eight or ten adults can be seen at lunch, together with a whole flock of children. Several generations lived side by side, worked together and came home to eat every day. In such a life, bottling the everyday wine made little sense. Even if every adult drank only a couple of glasses, an open bottle disappeared at once.

Later, the large table disappeared. From the late 1950s onwards, rural Italian society began to change at remarkable speed. Mateja’s aunts—Joško’s four elder sisters—belonged to the first generation of women from local farming families not merely to finish school, but to receive a university education. People began working away from home. Children moved to full-day schooling. Large family households broke down into smaller units of one or two adults and a few children.

It was not only relationships between people that changed. The very form of wine changed with them. In the 1960s, more than 70 per cent of Italian wine was sold in bulk. By the early 1980s, that share had fallen below 20 per cent. The shift is usually described as a move from low quality to high, but Mateja offers a more interesting explanation. Bulk wine was not necessarily bad; it had simply become inconvenient to keep in a small urban home, while the ten people who might once have finished it quickly were no longer gathered around the table.

The bottle thus became not only a symbol of Italian wine’s modernisation, but a monument to a vanished way of family life. Joško, the fifth child and only son, began bottling wine in the 1970s. In the following decade, like many ambitious Italian winemakers of his generation, he set off in pursuit of progress.

What one must never do

Progress had the seductive gleam of stainless steel. A new pneumatic press, modern filters, temperature-control equipment—in the 1980s, these were seen not merely as useful tools, but almost as prerequisites for quality. Joško bought the finest equipment and experimented with small 225- and 228-litre French barriques, then the object of near-universal fascination.

Yet even fashion he followed in his own way. The white wines spent their first year in small barrels and their second in steel, and were released only after two years of ageing. At the time, most Italian whites were bottled a few months after harvest, hurried onto the market by the following spring. From the beginning, Joško suspected that wine needed more time than the market was prepared to give it.

Gradually, another question began to trouble him. If high quality was truly impossible without ever more elaborate equipment, what did that say about the quality of the raw material? Why did grapes require so much correction if they had been grown properly?

In the mid-1980s, Joško travelled to California. European wines were often regarded then as old-fashioned—not nobly mature, merely dull. The New World, by contrast, seemed confident, vivid and technically immaculate. Joško wanted to understand the source of its success and what Italy ought to learn from it.

At one winery, he tasted a Sauvignon with exaggerated aromas that seemed almost to have been “added.” It was a sobering moment. When he returned home, his wife asked what the journey had taught him. Joško replied that he now knew what they must never do.

Yet California did not become for him a simplistic demonstration that everything new was bad. There, for the first time, he saw a fully organic winery, and he returned to Oslavia with a more difficult question: what does it mean to make a natural product in an environment that human beings simplify and destroy every day? He began not in the cellar, but in the vineyard.

The pond, the birds and the useless trees

In Gravner’s high-density plantings, more than 8,500 vines grew on a single hectare. Each had little more than a square metre to itself. Human beings decided where the vine should live, how much space it could occupy, how it should grow and how many grapes it should bear—and then demanded raw material of exceptional quality.

Joško saw a contradiction. One cannot expect healthy grapes from a plant living in an impoverished environment. And so other forms of life began to return to the monocultural landscape.

Olive, cherry, apricot, peach, pear and persimmon trees appeared among the vines. The family eats some of the fruit or turns it into jam; the trees generate no meaningful income. But, as Mateja says, agriculture cannot be based solely on what yields a direct profit.

The Gravners then turned their attention to the disappearance of birds. They studied the species that had once inhabited the area and installed nesting boxes in the vineyards. A pond was created in each vineyard. Visitors often call them lakes—perhaps because the word “pond” conjures stagnant water and mosquitoes. But a living pond is more complex: frogs control insects; birds come to drink and bathe, then remain in the vineyard and feed on pests.

All of this sounds almost idyllic until one remembers Oslavia’s climate. The area receives between 1,300 and 1,600 millimetres of rain a year—roughly as much as Bordeaux—with hours of sunshine comparable to Tuscany. A magnificent combination for plants, animals and people. And an equally magnificent one for vine disease.

Here, ponds, trees and birds are neither pastoral decoration nor an expensive performance staged for visitors. They are the vineyard’s working infrastructure, allowing human intervention to be reduced. If birds have somewhere to live and drink, they do not raid the crop. If they eat harmful insects, the winegrower has no need to treat the vines against them.

Joško gradually converted to organic farming. The grapes grew cleaner and cleaner. Yet it was precisely then that the original question became more urgent still. Why did the finest Ribolla he was capable of growing still fail to become the finest wine?

The taste left in the skins

Ribolla Gialla has lived on these hills for more than a thousand years. It has had ample time to adapt to the place: to generous rainfall, sunshine and a long growing season. It ripens late—in October, sometimes closer to November. Its berries are relatively large, but what matters most lies on the outside: a thick, crisp skin.

Mateja describes ripe Ribolla in almost tactile terms. With most wine grapes, bite into a berry and what remains in the mouth is juice and a faint trace of flavour; one barely notices the skin. Ribolla must be chewed. It retains a physical presence, and with it a significant share of the grape’s complexity. Modern white-wine production began by separating juice from skins as quickly as possible. With Ribolla, this meant removing the part in which the variety spoke most loudly.

Joško turned to history. For most of winemaking’s past, white and red grapes did not imply two fundamentally different cellar regimes: juice fermented together with the skins because there was simply no way to separate them immediately and gently. Wine was made in clay vessels of many shapes and sizes, depending on the place.

Clay did not necessarily give way to wood because wood was better. The amphorae were fragile. They were difficult to transport by road and almost impossible to ship without risking the loss of their entire contents. Barrels survived the journey and gradually became the universal vessel for storage and trade.

In 1996, working with what remained of the crop after the hail, Joško gave Ribolla back what modern technology had taken from it: its skins. For the first time, he heard the variety’s voice without translation. After that, there was no way back.

Nine shattered qvevri

Joško fermented the entire 1997 crop on its skins in large Slavonian oak vats. The maceration lasted four days. Today, when a white wine may spend months on its skins, this seems a cautious experiment. At the time, four days looked like madness.

That same year, he carried out his first fermentation in a small clay vessel buried in the ground. It was called an amphora, though “qvevri” would have been more precise. Amphora is a general term for clay vessels; Gravner uses Georgian qvevri, traditionally intended for fermenting and aging wine underground. But in the late 1990s, almost no one in Italy knew the word. Even its spelling confronted the family with a familiar borderland dilemma: qvevri in Italian, kvevri in Slovenian. The Gravners chose not to choose and called the vessels amphorae.

In 2000, Joško travelled to Georgia in search of craftsmen who still knew how to make them. A market for qvevri effectively did not exist: one could not open a catalogue, choose a capacity and arrange international delivery. Joško found elderly makers, bought eleven vessels and organised their transport from Tbilisi to Oslavia.

He had expected to ferment the 2000 harvest in them. The lorry arrived in November, long after the harvest had ended. But the delay proved the lesser problem: of the eleven qvevri, nine arrived shattered.

Joško returned to Georgia and began again. The first full fermentation in qvevri took place in 2001. By 2004, there were enough vessels for the entire crop, and since 2006 all production—including a small quantity of red wine—has been fermented in them.

Gravner’s qvevri hold between 2,000 and 2,800 litres, yet their walls are only two or three centimetres thick. The surrounding earth protects the vessel from the pressure of the liquid while regulating fermentation temperature. Joško saw in this not simply a technical advantage, but a way out of the very logic of standardisation.

After a hot summer, the grapes enter the cellar and meet earth that has retained the season’s warmth. In a cool, rainy year, the ground around the qvevri also remains cooler. Fermentation temperature is determined not by a setting chosen by the winemaker, but by the character of the vintage. The wine is not isolated from the year it has lived through; fermentation becomes a continuation of ripening.

The human role does not disappear. One must grow the healthiest, ripest grapes possible, observe the fermentation and make sure nothing goes wrong. But to observe is not to impose.

Mateja compares it to raising a child. You cannot assign a child a character or choose their personality in advance. You can only create the conditions in which they are able to realise their fullest potential.

The price of time

The first Ribolla to be fermented entirely in qvevri, in 2001, spent a year in clay and two more in large Slavonian oak casks. It was released in 2005. Tasting the wine after its release, the Gravners concluded that they had made a mistake: they had released it too soon.

The qvevri wines developed more slowly than they had expected. They needed more time for the tannins to soften, the texture to cohere and the sediment to settle naturally. The solution seemed simple: age them longer. For an estate that lived entirely from wine, it was almost unbearable.

Gravner had no entry-level range that could be sold a year after the harvest while the principal wine slowly matured in the cellar. Qvevri were neither an experimental cuvée nor the apex of a commercial pyramid—they held everything. Extending the ageing period meant postponing the income from an entire crop.

The timeline lengthened gradually, with another six months or a year added from one vintage to the next. The 2007 vintage was not bottled until 2014. That rhythm remains in place today: after harvest, the grapes are crushed without delay, then spend between three and five months on their skins in qvevri. Once separated from the skins, the wine returns to clay to complete its first year, before aging for a further six years in large old casks.

During that time, the sediment slowly sinks to the bottom. The wine becomes clear without physical or chemical filtration. The tannins extracted from the skins soften, the palate rounds out and new layers emerge. Seven years is not a theatrical gesture, nor patience cultivated for its own sake. Gravner releases a wine when its work is considered complete.

In Mateja’s view, waiting until a wine is ready is the producer’s responsibility, not the buyer’s. She compares a winery to a restaurant: a guest is not served a raw piece of meat and asked to finish cooking it to the desired degree of doneness. A buyer may leave a bottle in the cellar for another ten years if they enjoy mature wines. But they should not be forced to do so merely because the producer was in a hurry to recoup the investment.

Statistically, most bottles bought by private customers are opened within a day or a day and a half of purchase. This is not a failure of consumer discipline; it is reality. The wine must therefore be ready at the moment it passes into the buyer’s hands. The buyer’s freedom begins where the winemaker’s work ends.

Not for everyone?

Gravner’s wines are often said to be “not for everyone.” The phrase is at once a compliment, a warning and a little piece of snobbery. It surrounds the bottle with an aura of intellectual difficulty before the cork has even been drawn. Mateja disagrees.

Long maceration gives a white wine tannins, while seven years of ageing create multiple layers of aroma and flavour. But complexity is not the same as complication. It does not demand that anyone pass an examination before taking the first sip. Mateja compares such a wine to a museum visited by children. They may know nothing of art history, yet one will be drawn to colour, another to form, a third to some strange detail in the background. Experience allows us to see more, but the absence of experience does not cancel the immediacy of the encounter.

Why diminish diversity merely so that everything resembles what we already know? If all our friends were exactly like us, Mateja observes, conversation would soon grow dull. It would be easier simply to stand before a mirror. Gravner’s wine offers not a riddle with a single correct answer, but a space in which each person may choose their own path.

The return to the table

Paradoxically, these wines—now collectors’ objects and symbols of radical Italian winemaking—retain the memory of the large farmhouse table with which the family’s story began.

Gravner Ribolla is called a white wine, though at the table it is treated more like a wine freed from the discipline of colour. It stands up to meat, fish in rich sauces, cheese, risotto, pasta, omelettes with wild herbs and thick vegetable soups such as the local jota. It does not require one impeccably calculated pairing. It can travel through an entire meal.

It was precisely this freedom that made Gravner’s wines especially attractive to restaurants at a time when serving wine by the glass was not yet commonplace. One bottle could accompany several courses without demanding a constant change of gastronomic partner. Today, it may appear alongside the refined cuisine of La Subida or L’Argine a Vencò, but the wine’s inner logic remains the same: it was made not for the solitary contemplation of a label, but for food, conversation and time spent together. The large family table has vanished. The wine has preserved its shape.

Back to the future

Joško Gravner is often portrayed as a man who turned back the clock on winemaking: he rejected modern technology, travelled to Georgia and revived a method thousands of years old. But that version is too simple. He never rejected progress as such. He rejected the idea that every new device automatically makes the result better.

His journey was not an escape from modernity, but a sequence of practical questions.

If the equipment matters more than the grapes, are the grapes good enough?

If purity is achieved by destroying an ecosystem, what exactly do we mean by purity?

If Ribolla’s character resides in its skins, why remove them at once?

If the year’s temperature is already inscribed on the earth, why should the winemaker replace it with a standardised number?

If the wine needs seven years, why should the person who buys it be the one forced to wait?

At every stage, the answer meant relinquishing another layer of control. Yet this relinquishing of control did not amount to non-intervention, and certainly not to inaction. Growing healthy grapes in Oslavia’s humid climate, watching over fermentation for months, waiting years without a quick-release wine to pay the bills—all of this requires far more attention and resolve than pressing a button on a cooling system. Gravner did not return to the past. He took from the past a tool that allowed him to hear the present more clearly.

Photo Credits: www.gravner.it and Anna Obukhovskaia’s personal archive

Listen to the Full Conversation with Mateja Gravner:

A Glass in One Hand, a Book in the Other: Welcome to the Italian Wine Podcast Book Club

A Glass in One Hand, a Book in the Other: Welcome to the Italian Wine Podcast Book Club

Perché Nessuno Festeggia con l’Acqua?

Perché Nessuno Festeggia con l’Acqua?

When wine and war collide – in conversation with Don and Petie Kladstrup

When wine and war collide – in conversation with Don and Petie Kladstrup