By Marissa Muoio | Guest Contributor
“Wine is not just a simple product,” Andrea Contucci told me as we stood in the cool, stone depths of his centuries-old cellar, “it is a continuous presence that has accompanied the growth and development of 40 generations of Contucci. The Vino Nobile di Montepulciano is like a relative—it is part of us.”
His words settled in my bones like poetry. A thousand years of family history distilled not just into a lineage, but into a living relationship with the land, with culture, and with community. In Montepulciano, wine isn’t just grown—it’s remembered. It’s trusted. It’s loved.
This piece is a follow-up to Episode 521 of the Italian Wine Podcast featuring the luminous Caterina Dei. That conversation, and my own visit with Andrea Contucci, opened a portal into something deeper than winemaking. They revealed a Montepulciano that breathes with spiritual and cultural resonance—a place where tradition is not a fixed monument, but a rhythm of care passed from hand to hand, glass to glass.
Photo credit Cantine DEI
A Region That Speaks
Montepulciano, nestled in the heart of Tuscany, is often praised for its panoramic beauty and its noble wines. But listening to Dei and Contucci speak about their homeland, you begin to realize: this is more than a scenic wine destination. It is a sacred landscape shaped by memory and vision.
“Montepulciano is one of the oldest wine regions in Italy,” Andrea told me, “dating back to the Etruscan era as a land of wine. Wine has helped the cultural and artistic growth of our area. The noble families of Montepulciano (Contucci included), who are the origin of the fame of Vino Nobile di Montepulciano, are the same ones who contributed to making our city rich in art, which is why it is called the Pearl of the 1500s.”
This connection between viticulture and the humanities—between fermentation and fresco—is not incidental. It’s embedded in the soil, in the architecture, in the way the people of Montepulciano speak of their work. Wine here is not a product of the land. It is the land, told in story and song.
Caterina Dei, with her background in the arts, echoes this sentiment. She sees winemaking not only as a craft but as a form of creative translation. “There is no contradiction,” she said in her conversation with Cynthia Chaplin on Voices, “between tradition and innovation, if you are faithful to your place.”
Together, Dei and Contucci offer a compelling dual portrait of Montepulciano as both a bastion of heritage and a living laboratory of meaning.
Tradition as Stewardship
In an age when “heritage” is often used as a branding tool, it’s refreshing to encounter voices that treat it as a responsibility rather than a slogan.
The Contucci family has been producing wine in Montepulciano for over a millennium. Ten centuries. Forty generations. This isn’t legacy as inheritance; it’s legacy as vocation.
Photo credit Cantina Contucci
“We certainly try to convey our family values, our love for our land, our passion for what we do, and our friendship for those who come to visit us,” Andrea told me. There was no pretense in his tone. Just a grounded sincerity that echoed in every corner of his family’s palazzo.
Caterina, too, carries forward a family lineage—not by replicating the past, but by asking what it means to be a faithful interpreter of it. Her wines are intentional expressions of identity and place, rooted in Sangiovese but open to nuance and evolution.
Their shared philosophy—of honoring tradition not by freezing it, but by nourishing it—underscores the moral dimension of winemaking. Both Dei and Contucci understand that to tend vines is to tend something more than agriculture. It is to tend memory, and culture, and community.
Wine as Witness
As an educator and writer, I often reflect on what it means to accompany others—whether in learning, in grief, in joy. Andrea’s description of wine as “a continuous presence” reminded me of the best teachers I’ve known: quiet, steady, generous, never imposing but always there.
“Having opened the winery to visitors many years ago, long before what we in Italy call enoturismo (wine tourism) was born,” he told me, “we receive tens of thousands of visitors every year from all over the world. The telling of this story spanning over 1000 years and the presence of the family makes the visit a beautiful and rare experience, making this part of our offer the most important of all.”
What Andrea offers isn’t just wine. It’s witness. To walk through the Contucci cellar is to enter a living archive. Each bottle is a page in an ongoing narrative—of seasons, of choices, of patience. The air itself carries the gravity of time.
Caterina’s vineyards, too, speak in this language of accompaniment. Her wines are bold yet tender, elegant but never ostentatious. They speak without shouting. “Wine is the place we belong to,” she says. And belonging, as we know, is not just about origin. It’s about presence. About remaining.
An Ethical Craft
As our global wine culture becomes increasingly commodified, voices like Dei and Contucci feel prophetic. They call us back to something elemental: craft as care.
Andrea’s wines are not engineered to dazzle; they are composed to endure. His commitment to native yeasts, long fermentation, and minimal intervention is less about romanticism and more about respect. “You don’t need to manipulate something that already has character,” he told me. That line stayed with me. It felt less like a comment on winemaking and more like a worldview.
Photo credit Cantine DEI
Caterina’s artistry is similarly humble and brave. She allows the vineyard to speak. She listens more than she imposes. The result is a wine that is structurally complex yet spiritually accessible—a wine that wants to know you, not perform for you.
This is where winemaking becomes an ethical practice. Not neutral. Not decorative. But meaningful. To make something with this level of care is to declare what you believe about the world: that time matters. That soil matters. That people matter.
The Spiritual Dimension of Place
There is a spiritual undertone in both Dei and Contucci’s reflections—not in the religious sense necessarily, but in the way they speak with reverence and rootedness.
For Andrea, the vineyard is a testament. A generational heartbeat. A trust passed down through centuries not as possession but as presence.
For Caterina, the work is prayerful. A practice in stillness and courage. Her relationship to Montepulciano is one of deep attunement, and her wines reflect that musicality—balanced, resonant, echoing something ancient and holy.
Their perspectives suggest that wine is not just an object of pleasure, but a vessel of meaning. A form of communion between land and person, history and future, maker and drinker.
A Return, Not Just a Tasting
The wines of Montepulciano remind me that wine, like education, like art, like love, asks for presence. It asks us to listen. To return. To consider not just what we consume, but what we carry.
When Andrea said, “The Vino Nobile di Montepulciano is like a relative—it is part of us,” I felt a kind of recognition. Because good wine doesn’t just taste good. It knows you. It walks with you.
And perhaps that’s the truest offering of Montepulciano—not just its vino nobile, but its noble vision. A vision where craft is care. Where tradition is trust. Where soil becomes soul.


